What to Put in a Bridesmaid Proposal Box


This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and member of RewardStyle, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please visit our privacy policy for details.

Hey Future Mrs.! Feeling overwhelmed with picking the perfect goodies for your bridesmaid proposal boxes? Let me tell you, I’ve been there, done that – tried and tested more bridesmaid box fillers than I can count! Trust me to guide you through crafting those gift boxes with the ideal mix of heartwarming, useful, and personalized treasures that your squad will absolutely adore. Let’s make those boxes unforgettable, just like your big day! 🌟✨

My Top Picks for What to Put in a Bridesmaid Proposal Box

Each of these items has been selected with thoughtfulness and care, bringing a unique touch to your bridesmaid proposal boxes. With these recommendations, you’re already on your way to creating an exceptional and memorable gift for your bridesmaids.

bridesmaids in sage with beautiful flowers

Features & Product Aspects to Look For

Before jumping directly into the product recommendations, it’s crucial to understand the key aspects and features to look for in the items that go in your bridesmaid proposal box. Here are some factors to consider:

Sentimental Value

Remember, a bridesmaid proposal box is not only a fancy gift – it’s a heartfelt gesture that represents your special bond with each bridesmaid. Hence, look for items that hold sentimental value:

  • Perhaps a photo memory that captures a special moment.
  • A piece of jewelry that symbolizes your friendship.
  • Handwritten notes stand as a thoughtful touch.

Practical Usability

While the bridesmaid proposal box is a sentimental gesture, including practical items your bridesmaids can make use of is also a good idea. Consider their preferences and lifestyle:

  • A good quality candle can provide a relaxing atmosphere.
  • Skincare items like salt scrubs can be lovely treats.
  • Utility items like Stanley drinking cups can also make charming additions.

Personalization Options

Personalization can make the gift ten times more special. Keeping the bridesmaid’s tastes in mind and selecting items accordingly adds a thoughtful touch.

  • Selecting candles with their preferred scents.
  • Pajamas in their favorite color or preferred fabric.
  • Customized notes for each one, expressing unique memories or jokes you share.

Quality & Durability

While the gesture itself is truly more meaningful than the cost, you’d want to ensure you’re giving your loved ones gifts that are of good quality and durability.

  • High-quality jewelry can be worn on numerous occasions.
  • High-quality candles with pure ingredients are safer and healthier.
  • Stanley drinking cups are known for their excellent quality and durability.

In the next section, we’ll dive deeper into these products, examining the pros and cons of each.

Photo Memories

Overview: One of the first things you should consider including in your bridesmaid proposal box is a portion for photo memories. This could be a personalized photo album or even a simple, beautiful photo frame with a memorable picture of you together.

  • Pros:
    • Adds a personal and sentimental touch to the proposal
    • Photo memories can be a keepsake that your bridesmaids can cherish
  • Cons:
    • Some bridesmaids might have different aesthetic ideas when it comes to photo frames

Happy Wax Candles

Overview: Candles, particularly scented ones, are an elegant and practical addition to your bridesmaid proposal box. They provide relaxation, and can also serve as home decor.

  • Pros:
    • Offers a relaxing, soothing ambiance to your bridesmaids’ space
    • Comes in a variety of scents and designs to match personal preferences
  • Cons:
    • The scent might not align with everybody’s preference

lemon happy wax candle

Bare Botanics Body Scrub

Overview: Pamper your bridesmaids with a jar of salt scrubs. These beauty items can provide your bridesmaids a self-care routine that helps them prepare for your big day.

  • Pros:
    • Promotes relaxation and has skincare benefits
    • Can be used numerous times
  • Cons:
    • May be unsuitable for those with sensitive skin

Bare Botanics Unscented Body Scrub


Overview: Adding a piece of jewelry like a necklace, bracelet, or earrings that they can wear on the wedding day is another sweet and thoughtful idea.

  • Pros:
    • Adds elegance and serves a functional purpose on your wedding day
    • Your bridesmaids can treasure it as a memento of your big day
  • Cons:
    • Not all the bridesmaids might have the same taste in jewelry

Satin Pajamas

Overview: A set of satin pajamas ensures your bridesmaids get the restful sleep they need whilst also feeling chic and luxurious.

  • Pros:
    • Provides comfort and style
    • Can also serve as getting-ready attire for your wedding day if you choose
  • Cons:
    • Size and style preferences may vary among your bridesmaids

Bridesmaid matching Pajamas

Sweet Notes

Overview: A heartfelt note expressing your feelings and appreciations can be more valuable than any other item in the proposal box.

  • Pros:
    • Adds a personal and emotional touch to your proposal
    • Gives you the chance to express why you want them in your bridal party
  • Cons:
    • Some people are not as emotive and might not attach the same value to written sentiments

Personalized Coffee Cup with Birth Flower

Overview: Elevate your drinking experience with these unique and aesthetically pleasing glass cups. These cups are a perfect choice, whether you’re treating yourself, gifting your friends, or showing your love and appreciation to family members.

  • Pros:
    • Adds a personal and emotional touch to your proposal
    • Everyone loves coffee (but they can be used for mimosas on wedding morning, too!)
  • Cons:
    • They are glass and a little fragile, so you need to wrap them carefully

Personalized Coffee Cup with Birth Flower

Champagne Gummy Bears Candy

Overview: Sweeten the proposal with your bridesmaids’ favorite candies.

  • Pros:
    • Adds a fun and sweet touch to your proposal box
    • Wide variety to choose from according to their preference
  • Cons:
    • Can melt or get damaged if not packaged properly

Champagne Gummy Bears

Stanley Drinking Cups

Overview: Include a Stanley drinking cup in your bridesmaid proposal box to keep your bridal party quenched and stylish during the bachelorette party or even on the wedding day.

  • Pros:
    • Functional and sturdy
    • Can serve as a long-lasting souvenir for your bridesmaids
  • Cons:
    • Might not suit everyone’s style and taste

Stanley Quencher H2.0 FlowState

What to Put in a Bridesmaid Proposal Box Buying Guide

When making the decision on what to put in a bridesmaid proposal box, there are several variables to consider. Here’s a buying guide to help you craft the perfect proposal box for your bridesmaids.

Considering Your Bridesmaids’ Preferences

Each bridesmaid is unique with her own set of likes, dislikes and lifestyles. Consider what each bridesmaid might appreciate and use.

  • Reflect on your memories with them. Do they have a favorite scent, color, or hobby that you could incorporate?
  • Consider their lifestyle. Are they into fitness, travel or beauty?
  • Think about their individual fashion sense. Would they prefer something more subtle or a bold statement piece?

Evaluating Quality and Price

As with any other product, the quality and price matter when choosing items to include in your bridesmaid proposal box.

  • Make sure the products you choose are of good quality. You wouldn’t want to gift something that might break or stop working after one use.
  • Prices may vary from product to product. Assess how much you’re willing to spend on the items to make sure you stay within your budget.

Shopping With Time in Mind

Remember, collecting items for your bridesmaid’s proposal box may take time.

  • Start planning and shopping early to ensure you have adequate time to gather all your chosen items.
  • Including personalized items might necessitate additional production and shipping time.

Looking for Personalization Features

Adding a personal touch to the items can make the proposal box even more special.

  • Consider items that can be personalized, such as monogrammed goods or custom jewelry pieces.
  • A handwritten note can also add a personal touch to your bridesmaid proposal box.

By considering these points you can ensure you’re assembling a bridesmaid proposal box that’s thoughtful, personal, and sure to be appreciated by each of your bridesmaids.


Customizing a Ready-Made Proposal Box

Another alternative is to buy a readymade proposal box and then customize it according to each bridesmaids’ preference.

  • This is a perfect balance of convenience and personalization.
  • You can add or remove items as required.
  • This will save time but still shows effort and thoughtfulness.

Remember that the most important element in proposing to your bridesmaids is to show them how much they mean to you, and how much you value their support on your special day. A sincere proposal can often mean more than what’s inside the box.

Conclusion: Wrapping Up Your Best Bridesmaid Proposal Box Choices

Having traversed through a myriad of sentimental, practical, personalized, and quality items, our top recommendations for what to put in your bridesmaid proposal box truly span photo memories, candles, salt scrubs, jewelry, satin pajamas, sweet notes, candy, and Stanley drinking cups.

  • Having a mix of items in your bridesmaid proposal box adds variety and caters to different tastes.
  • Sentimentality is key – consider items like photo memories and sweet notes that can create a strong emotional connection.
  • Practical items, such as satin pajamas and Stanley drinking cups, ensure the gifts are not only heartfelt but also useful.
  • Personalized items like jewelry or specially picked out candles add a unique touch to the proposal box, showing thoughtfulness.
  • Evaluation of product quality and price is essential in the process, allowing for a balance between luxury and affordability.
  • Consideration of your bridesmaids’ preferences and individuality when choosing products ensures the gifts are more personal and well-received.
  • Remember to take time constraints into account when shopping, as personalization and shipping might take longer than regular purchases.

In summary, curating a bridesmaid proposal box is a thoughtful process that resonates with your affection and appreciation for your bridal party. It’s about delivering a blend of love, sentimentality, and utility in a neatly packed box. Keep these tips in mind, and your bridesmaid proposal boxes are sure to delight your tribe.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I consider when choosing products for my bridesmaid proposal box?

When choosing products for your bridesmaid proposal box, think about the preferences and tastes of your bridesmaids. Consider items that they would find appealing, useful, or fitting their unique personality. Also look at the quality and price of items to ensure they are valuable and fall within your budget.

How can I personalize the bridesmaid proposal box to fit each bridesmaid’s personality?

Personalizing the bridesmaid proposal box can be as simple as selecting a unique item that resonates with each bridesmaid’s taste or interest. This could be a specific type of candy they love, a piece of jewelry that fits their style, or a personal message that encapsulates your bond with them.

Is it necessary to spend a lot on a bridesmaid proposal box?

While it’s important to choose items of high quality, spending a lot on a bridesmaid proposal box is not always necessary. There are plenty of meaningful and valuable items that are budget-friendly. The key is to ensure the items show thoughtful consideration and appreciation, regardless of the cost.

Where can I find the items for my bridesmaid proposal box?

Items for your bridesmaid proposal box can be found in a variety of places. Online marketplaces like Etsy, Amazon, and other wedding-centric websites have a vast selection, especially for personalized goods. Local boutiques or specialty stores may also carry unique items that fit your bridesmaids’ tastes.

More Wedding Planning Posts You Will Love

Share this post

comments +

Leave a Reply

follow us On instagram:



follow our studio space: